> > And love-spoons are a part of at least one culture:
> > http://www.lovespoons-wales.co.uk/
I wish I could believe this, but I have to say it sounds far-fetched.
And awfully like an object invented to sell to the tourists. Does anyone
have more connecting this "spoon" to the other one?
> To my mind, the sexual use of spooning (a form of bundling) is a more
> likely source:
>
> http://www.sexualpositionsfree.com/spooning.html
Source of what? You think, at the turn of the century, people gathered
round the piano and sang songs about sexual positions?
Shine on, shine on harvest moon up in the sky
I ain't had no lovin' since January, February, June,
or July
Snow time ain't no time to sit outdoors and spoon
Shine on, shine on harvest moon for me 'n' my gal
What have we got for early citations for this verb?... DAE (1938) does
have the meaning "to lie spoon-fashion" from 1715 to 1887. The citations
imply nestling together to save space on a bunk, or for warmth... Hmmm,
nothing about courtship or affection. Except one meaning as a noun, that
"the spoons" can mean "sentimental affection," 1846.
Tantalizing, but not very conclusive. Is the OED any better?
Maybe Tin Pan Alley needed a rhyme *and* a new euphemism, so they made
it up.

Signature
Best - Donna Richoux
John Dean - 10 Jan 2004 17:02 GMT
>>> And love-spoons are a part of at least one culture:
>>> http://www.lovespoons-wales.co.uk/
>
> I wish I could believe this, but I have to say it sounds far-fetched.
> And awfully like an object invented to sell to the tourists. Does
> anyone have more connecting this "spoon" to the other one?
According to this ...
http://www.hardcorecarvers.co.uk/lovespoons/lovespoons3.html
... there are such spoons dating back several hundred years. Which is not to
say that, like most folk art, they haven't become tourist-milkers by now.
OED has a cite << 1918 W. R. Butterfield in Connoisseur Aug. 191/1 At
first,+*love-spoons did not differ greatly from the wooden spoons in
ordinary use in the household. >> suggesting they are of sufficient
antiquity that someone in 1918 could write a history of them.
>> To my mind, the sexual use of spooning (a form of bundling) is a more
>> likely source:
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
>
> Tantalizing, but not very conclusive. Is the OED any better?
OED (verb) :
<< 4. a. intr. To lie close together, to fit into each other, in the manner
of spoons.
1887 Harper's Mag. Apr. 781/2 Two persons in each bunk, the sleepers
‘spooning’ together, packed like sardines. 1894 Outing XXIV. 343/2 The
precision with which we could ‘spoon’ that sad night was truly beautiful to
behold. >>
<< II. 6. intr. a. To make love, esp. in a sentimental or silly fashion.
colloq.
1831 Lady Granville Lett. (1894) II. 77 The billiard room, in which they
spooned. 1864 Meredith Emilia xxxvi, You might have—pardon the
slang—spooned, who knows? 1872 Lever Ld. Kilgobbin lxxix, So long as a man
spoons, he can talk of his affection. 1898 Wollocombe Fr. Morn till Eve
vii. 84 Many danced, while others spooned under the influence of the summer
moonlight. >>
<< 7. trans. To court or pay addresses to (a person), esp. in a sentimental
manner.
1877 Mrs. Forrester Mignon I. 252 It was pleasant to spoon her when there
was nothing else to do. 1894 K. Grahame Pagan Papers 148 When a Fellow was
spooning his sister once, they used to employ him to carry notes. >>
OED (noun):
<< 8. a. to be spoons with, about, or on, to be sentimentally in love with
(a girl). slang.
c1859 J. S. Coyne Everybody's Friend i. i. 7 It was one of my nonsensical
effusions, when I was spoons about you.+ Mrs. F. Spoons! Feath. Well, when I
was dying in love with you, my dear. 1860 Slang Dict. 224 ‘When I was
spoons with you,’ i.e., when young, and in our courting days before
marriage. >>
<< b. pl. Without const.: Sentimental or silly fondness. Also applied to
persons: Sweethearts. Rarely in sing., an instance of sentimental love-play;
a fond lover.
1846 Spirit of Times 18 Apr. 92/2 The girls are beautiful, with a very
liberal allowance of ‘the spoons’, as our friend Smith would say. 1868 E.
Yates Rocks Ahead ii. ii, This time it's an awful case of spoons. 1882 H.
C. Merivale Faucit of B. III. ii. xii. 42 They were old spoons too when they
were young. 1888 Gunter Mr. Potter x. 127 The moment he saw Ethel it became
a wonderful case of ‘spoons’ upon his part. c1921 D. H. Lawrence Mod. Lover
(1934) 188 A young chap goes out on Sunday night for a bit of a spoon. >>
OED says of 'bundle':
<< 5. intr. To sleep in one's clothes on the same bed or couch with (as was
formerly customary with persons of opposite sexes, in Wales and New
England).
1781 S. Peters Gen. Hist. Connecticut (Bartlett) It is thought but a
piece of civility to ask [a lady] to bundle. 1809 W. Irving Knickerb.
(Bartlett) Van Corlear stopped occasionally in the villages to+dance at
country frolics, and bundle with the Yankee lasses.>>
Which suggests that bundling was an activity limited to a small geographic
area whereas spooning was widespread. There is also no indication I can find
anywhere that 'bundling' implied sleeping spoon-fashion - merely that a
couple shared a bed while fully dressed. If I'd been put in a bed with my
love I'd have wanted to be face to face throughout.
--
John Dean
Oxford
De-frag to reply